Skip to main content

Table 1 Characteristics of the 9 included studies

From: The prevalence of cryptococcal antigen (CrAg) and benefits of pre-emptive antifungal treatment among HIV-infected persons with CD4+ T-cell counts < 200 cells/μL: evidence based on a meta-analysis

Author, year (reference)

Number of participants

Study type

Study duration

Age (years)

CD4 (cells/μL)

CrAg screening methods

CM diagnostic methods

Location

Therapeutic regimens

Primary outcomes

Incidence of CM

All-cause mortality

Chariyalertsak, 2002 [18]

129

Prospective study

104 weeks

18 ~ 60

<200

Not report

Fungal culture, a histopathological examination, or buffy coat smear

Thailand

63 for oral itraconazole (200 mg/day) as group 1; 66 for matched placebo as group 2

0 in group 1; 7 in group 2

12 in group 1; 11 in group 2

Manfredi, 1997 [19]

249

Retrospective study

6 years

22 ~ 59

<200

Not report

Specific polysaccharide antigen detection from body fluids

Italy

128 for oral fluconazole (100 mg/d every third week) as group 1; 121 for no antifungal treatment as group 2

2 in group 1; 9 in group 2

12 in group 1; 13 in group 2

Parkes-Ratanshi, 2011 [20]

1519

Prospective study

42 months

Not report

<200

Not report

CrAg titre> 1:8 on two occasions, or a positive CSF CrAg or Cryptococcus neoformans grown from blood or CSF culture

Uganda

760 fluconazole 200 mg 3 times per week for minimum 12 weeks as group 1; 759 allocated to placebo as group 2

1 in group 1; 18 in group 2

0 in group 1; 7 in group 2

McKinsey, 1999 [21]

295

Randomized, placebo-Controlled study

Not report

≥13

<150

Not report

Fungal culture

Not report

149 for itraconazole capsules (200 mg/day) as group 1; 146 for matched placebo as 2

1 in group 1; 8 in group 2

32 in group 1; 21 in group 2

Meya, 2010 [22]

584

Prospective study

30 months

≥18

<200

Not report

Not report

Uganda

Fluconazole (200 ~ 400 mg) for 2 ~ 4 weeks

3 in CrAg+ persons and 0 in CrAg- persons

6 in CrAg+ persons and 0 in CrAg- persons

Kapoor, 2015 [23]

72

Retrospective study

15 months

≥18

<200

LFA

Positive CSF India ink

Sub-Saharan Africa

800 mg fluconazole orally for 2 weeks, followed by 400 mg orally for 2 weeks

0 in CrAg+ persons and 1 in CrAg- persons

2 in CrAg+ persons and 8 in CrAg- persons

Govender, 2015a [1]

1079

Retrospective study

19 months

Not report

< 200

LA or the Latex-Cryptococcus antigen detection system

CrAg detected in CSF

South Africa

Fluconazole ranging from 400 to 800 mg per day for at least 3 months

unknow in persons with CD4 < 200

unknow in persons with CD4 < 200

Beyene, 2017 [10]

783

Prospective study

18 months

> 14

≤150

LFA

CSF CrAg

Ethiopia

Fluconazole 800 mg/day 2 weeks, followed by 400 mg/day 8 weeks

2 in CrAg+ persons and 0 in CrAg- persons

4 in CrAg+ persons and 0 in CrAg- persons

Borges, 2019 [24]

214

Prospective study

36 months

> 17

< 200

LFA

India ink microscopy on the CSF, CSF CrAg test and fungal culture

Brazil

Fluconazole 900 mg for 2 weeks, 450 mg for 8 to 10 weeks and a subsequent maintenance dose of 150–300 mg

1 in CrAg+ persons with antifungal treatment and 0 in CrAg+ persons without intervention

2 in CrAg+ persons

  1. “No” means “no data”; “Yes” means “data exists”; OIs means: other opportunity infections
  2. LFA Lateral flow assay, LA Latex Agglutination, LP Lumbar puncture
  3. a“Govender, 2015” study was included for evaluating the prevalence of CrAg positivity. Only the data in persons with CD4 < 200 was used