Skip to main content

Table 4 Incidence rate QFT conversion at visit 2 and visit 3 using different definitions of conversion

From: Interpretation of serial interferon-gamma test results to measure new tuberculosis infection among household contacts in Zambia and South Africa

 

Definition 1

(< 0.35, increase 0.35)

n = 439 negative at V1

Definition 2

(< 0.2, ≥0.7)

n = 374 negative at V1

Definition 3

(< 0.2, ≥1.05)

n = 374 negative at V1

Definition 4

(< 0.2, ≥1.4)

n = 374 negative at V1

Incident events

Person years

Incident

Rate (95%CI)

Incident events

Person years

Incident

Rate (95%CI)

Incident events

Person years

Incident

Rate (95%CI)

Incident events

Person years

Incident

Rate (95%CI)

Both countries

 Total

175

7.5

23.2 (20.0–26.9)

114

6.8

16.7 (13.9–20.0)

93

7.0

13.1 (10.7–16.1)

79

7.2

10.9 (8.7–13.6)

 End follow-up V1-V2

113

4.9

23.3 (19.3–27.9)

72

4.2

17.0 (13.5–21.5)

56

4.3

12.9 (9.9–16.8)

46

4.4

10.4 (7.8–13.9)

 End follow-up V2-V3

62

2.7

23.1 (18.0–29.6)

42

2.6

16.1 (11.9–21.8)

37

2.7

13.5 (9.8–18.6)

33

2.8

11.6 (8.2–16.3)

HIV status contact*

 HIV negative

125

4.6

27.4 (22.9–32.6)

78

4.1

19.0 (15.2–23.7)

63

4.3

14.7 (11.5–18.8)

53

4.4

12.0 (9.2–15.7)

 HIV positive, no ARV

42

2.7

15.8 (11.7–21.4)

30

2.4

12.3 (8.6–17.6)

24

2.5

9.7 (6.5–14.4)

22

2.5

8.8 (5.8–13.3)

 HIV positive & ARV

6

0.3

20.2 (9.1–44.9)

5

0.3

18.1 (7.5–43.4)

5

0.3

17.3 (7.2–41.5)

3

0.3

9.8 (3.2–30.5)

Zambia

 Total

131

5.2

25.1 (21.1–29.8)

87

4.9

17.6 (14.3–21.7)

72

5.1

14.0 (11.1–17.7)

63

5.2

12.0 (9.4–15.4)

 End follow-up V1-V2

77

3.1

25.1 (20.1–31.4)

50

2.8

17.9 (13.6–23.7)

38

2.9

13.3 (9.7–18.2)

33

2.9

11.4 (8.1–16.1)

 End follow-up V2-V3

54

2.1

25.0 (19.2–32.7)

37

2.1

17.2 (12.4–23.7)

34

2.3

15.0 (10.7–21.0)

30

2.3

12.8 (8.9–18.3)

HIV status contact*

 HIV negative

93

3.0

30.7 (25.0–37.6)

61

2.8

21.3 (16.6–27.4)

50

2.9

16.7 (12.7–22.1)

44

3.1

14.4 (10.7–19.3)

 HIV positive, no ARV

31

1.9

16.1 (11.3–22.9)

20

1.9

10.7 (6.9–16.6)

16

1.9

8.4 (5.1–13.7)

15

1.9

7.8 (4.7–13.0)

 HIV positive & ARV

5

0.2

20.7 (8.6–49.7)

5

0.2

24.6 (10.2–59.1)

5

0.2

23.2 (9.6–55.7)

3

0.2

12.9 (4.2–40.2)

Region by TST prevalence

 Lusaka, high TST

49

1.5

33.0 (24.9–43.7)

31

1.4

21.9 (15.4–31.2)

27

1.5

18.1 (12.4–26.4)

24

1.5

15.7 (10.5–23.5)

 Urban, high TST

39

1.5

26.3 (19.2–35.9)

27

1.4

19.5 (13.3–28.4)

20

1.5

13.8 (8.9–21.4)

18

1.5

12.2 (7.7–19.3)

 Urban, low TST

29

1.7

17.5 (12.2–25.2)

20

1.6

12.8 (8.2–19.9)

16

1.6

9.9 (6.1–16.3)

13

1.6

7.9 (4.6–13.7)

 Rural, low TST

14

0.6

23.4 (13.9–39.5)

9

0.6

15.3 (7.9–29.5)

9

0.6

15.3 (7.9–29.5)

8

0.6

13.4 (6.7–26.9)

South Africa

 Total

44

2.3

18.9 (14.1–25.5)

27

1.9

14.3 (9.8–20.8)

21

1.9

10.8 (7.0–16.5)

16

2.0

7.9 (4.9–13.0)

 End follow-up V1-V2

36

1.8

20.1 (14.5–27.8)

22

1.4

15.3 (10.1–23.3)

18

1.5

12.3 (7.7–19.5)

13

1.5

8.6 (4.9–14.8)

 End follow-up V2-V3

8

0.5

15.2 (7.6–30.5)

5

0.5

10.9 (4.6–26.4)

3

0.5

6.3 (2.0–19.5)

3

0.5

6.0 (1.9–18.6)

HIV status contact*

 HIV negative

32

1.5

20.8 (14.7–29.4)

17

1.2

13.6 (8.5–21.9)

13

1.3

10.0 (5.8–17.3)

9

1.4

6.7 (3.5–12.8)

 HIV positive, no ARV

11

0.7

15.2 (8.4–27.4)

10

0.6

17.6 (9.5–32.8)

8

0.6

13.6 (6.9–27.6)

7

0.6

11.9 (5.7–25.1)

 HIV positive & ARV

1

0.1

17.9 (2.5–127.0)

0

0.1

N.A.

0

0.1

N.A.

0

0.1

N.A.

TST prevalence

 High

27

1.1

25.1 (17.2–36.7)

15

0.9

16.9 (10.2–28.1)

11

0.9

11.8 (6.6–21.4)

9

0.9

9.3 (4.8–17.8)

 Low

17

1.2

13.6 (8.5–21.9)

12

1.0

11.9 (6.8–21.0)

10

1.0

9.8 (5.3–18.3)

7

1.0

6.7 (3.2–14.0)

  1. Footnote: Contacts with visit 2 unknown and conversion at visit 3 were randomly assigned to have end point follow-up between visit 1-visit 2 (V1-V2) or visit 2-visit 3 (V2-V3). Table A4 (additional file) shows that this includes n = 27 household contacts if conversion definition 2 is used. Number of contacts who were randomly allocated for the other definitions: n = 41 definition 1; n = 21 definition 3; n = 19 definition 4 *HIV status unknown not shown
  2. IRs and 95% CIs reported as number of conversion events per 100 person-years of follow-up time