Skip to main content

Table 4 Subgroup and sensitivity analyses

From: A meta-analysis of ventriculostomy-associated cerebrospinal fluid infections

Comparison

n

Infections/1000 catheter-days

Lower 95% CI a

Upper 95% CI

p

I-squared (%)

Overall

35

11.4

9.3

13.5

0.004

44

Subgroups

Culture frequency

Daily culture

5

10.8

4.8

16.8

0.16

39

Culture when indicated

15

11.2

8.6

13.9

0.16

27

Other culture regimes

15

13.5

9.6

17.4

0.048

41

Infection definition

Culture proven infection

18

11.5

8.4

14.6

0.004

54

CDC definition of infection

5

8.8

6.3

11.3

0.403

0.50

Culture plus other features

5

9.1

4.8

13.4

0.436

0

Culture or other features

7

17

10

24.1

0.347

11

Age group

      

Paediatric

3

10.6

6.1

15.2

0.429

0

Adult

32

11.5

9.3

13.7

0.002

48

Year

      

Publication year <2000

5

18.3

12.4

24.3

0.39

3

Publication year 2000+

30

10.5

8.4

12.6

0.002

47

Duration

      

Mean duration <7 days

6

19.6

10

24.1

0.6

0

Mean duration 7-10 days

14

12.8

9.5

16

0.03

49

Mean duration >10 days

15

8

5.4

10.5

0.106

37

Study type

      

Prospective

5

11

6.6

15.4

0.23

29

Retrospective

30

11.4

9.1

13.8

0.003

47

AIC

      

No AIC

18

10.8

8.1

13.6

0.001

57

Unclear

13

13.7

9.8

17.6

0.19

25

AIC used

4

7.2

2.6

14.1

0.64

0

Sensitivity Analysis

Study size

      

<=1000 catheter-days

13

18.3

13.4

23.3

0.34

11

>1000 catheter-days

22

9

6.8

11.2

0.027

40

Newcastle-Ottawa score

1 and 2

11

13.5

8.9

18.1

0.046

46

3 and 4

24

10.6

8.3

13

0.019

41

  1. aCI = confidence interval.