Point-prevalence survey of outpatient antibiotic prescription at a tertiary medical center in Sri Lanka: opportunities to improve prescribing practices for respiratory illnesses

Abstract

Background

Inappropriate antibiotic use is linked to the spread of antimicrobial resistance worldwide, but there are limited systemic data on antibiotic utilization in low- and middle-income countries. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the prevalence and patterns of antibiotic prescription in an ambulatory care setting in Sri Lanka.

Methods

This cross-sectional survey was conducted at the Outpatient Department of a public tertiary medical center in Southern Province, Sri Lanka from February to April 2019. Among consecutive outpatients presenting for care, questionnaires were verbally administered to a systematic random sample to capture information about patient demographics, illness characteristics, and visit outcomes. Prescription data were obtained from the outpatient pharmacy’s electronic prescribing system.

Results

Of 409 surveyed patients, 146 (35.7%) were prescribed an antibiotic. The most frequently prescribed agents were amoxicillin (41 patients, 28.1% of antibiotic recipients) and first-generation cephalosporins (38, 26.0%). Respiratory indications were the most common reason for antibiotic use, comprising 69 (47.3%) of all antibiotic prescriptions. Antibiotics were prescribed for 66.1% of patients presenting with cough and 78.8% of those presenting with rhinorrhea or nasal congestion. Among all antibiotic recipients, 6 (4.1%) underwent diagnostic studies.

Conclusions

A high prevalence of antibiotic prescription was observed, in particular for treatment of respiratory conditions. These data support the need for improved antimicrobial stewardship in the Sri Lankan outpatient setting.

Background

The emergence and spread of antimicrobial resistance (AMR) poses a serious global public health threat. Annually, antimicrobial-resistant infections contribute to an estimated 23,000 deaths in the United States and 25,000 deaths in Europe [1, 2]. While reliable estimates are lacking in low- and middle- income countries (LMICs), morbidity and mortality attributable to AMR are expected to be even greater in these settings due to a higher prevalence of infectious diseases and lesser access to newer-generation antibiotics [3].

Although epidemiologic surveillance of AMR in Sri Lanka has only recently been implemented, available data reveal a high prevalence of infections caused by drug-resistant organisms. In a multi-center study of gram-negative bacterial bloodstream infections, organisms producing extended-spectrum beta-lactamases (ESBLs) accounted for nearly one-quarter of isolated pathogens [4]. Additionally, national surveillance data of urine culture isolates demonstrated resistance to ciprofloxacin and third-generation cephalosporins at proportions exceeding 50% among enteric gram-negative bacteria [5].

Decades of widespread antibiotic use have created selective pressure for the development of AMR, with increasing antibiotic consumption especially pronounced in LMICs [6]. A recent point-prevalence survey of antimicrobial use in Sri Lankan public hospitals revealed that more than one-half of all inpatients and nearly all patients in intensive care wards were receiving antimicrobials at the time of survey; approximately one-third of antimicrobials were deemed to be potentially inappropriate [7]. Systematic data on outpatient antimicrobial prescribing practices in Sri Lanka, however, remain limited. A 2015 multi-center prescription audit performed in Sri Lanka by the World Health Organization South-East Asia Regional Office reported that 45–67% of patients receiving medications from public pharmacies and 21–27% of private pharmacy clients were prescribed an antibiotic [8]. There are no studies that systematically examine outpatient antibiotic prescription in the context of patient-level data in Sri Lanka.

In this study, we determined the point prevalence of antibiotic prescription and assessed demographic and clinical patterns associated with antibiotic prescription among outpatients at a public tertiary healthcare facility in Southern Province, Sri Lanka.

Methods

Setting

This cross-sectional study was conducted at a 1600-bed public tertiary teaching hospital located in the Southern Province of Sri Lanka. The hospital provides both inpatient and outpatient services free of cost. Outpatient services include an Outpatient Department (OPD) offering ambulatory acute care services to upwards of 1000 patients per day. The majority of OPD patients are local residents who present by self-referral. The hospital has an on-site outpatient pharmacy to which OPD prescriptions are electronically sent.

Survey procedures

Pre- and post-visit questionnaires were developed explicitly for this study (Supplementary file 1). Pediatric and adult OPD patients were recruited on consecutive weekdays from February to April 2019 to participate in the study survey. Systematic random sampling was performed by approaching every fifth patient in the OPD waiting queue for study enrollment. Written consent was obtained from patients ≥18 years of age and from the parent/guardian of patients < 18 years, and assent was additionally obtained from patients 12–17 years. After obtaining consent, the pre-visit questionnaire was verbally administered in the local language of Sinhala to obtain information regarding the participant’s demographics, presenting illness, medical co-morbidities, and expectations for the doctor’s visit. Immediately following the doctor’s visit, the post-visit questionnaire was verbally administered to obtain information regarding visit diagnoses, diagnostic tests that were ordered or reviewed during the visit, patient knowledge and perceptions regarding antibiotics, and patient satisfaction with the visit. Prior to being asked questions about antibiotics, all respondents were provided with a definition of antibiotics using lay terminology. For each OPD patient participating in the study, the OPD pharmacy’s electronic prescribing system was queried to obtain information regarding medications prescribed during the visit.

Data analysis

Survey data were entered into a Research Electronic Data Capture (REDCap) database. Statistical analysis was performed in R version 3.6.3 (Vienna, Austria). Missing responses were omitted from denominators used to calculate simple proportions. Fisher’s exact test with odds ratios and 95% confidence intervals was used to identify demographic and clinical features associated with antibiotic prescription. Two-tailed p-values were used, and a p-value less than 0.05 was used to define statistical significance.

Results

Patient demographics and clinical characteristics

Of 409 total patients enrolled, 88 (21.6%) were children under 18 years of age and 153 (37.5%) were male (Table 1). Median patient age was 38 (interquartile range [IQR] 19–54) years. Chronic medical conditions were reported among 128 (31.4%) patients, with the most common conditions being hypertension (49, 12.0%) and hyperlipidemia (40, 9.8%). The most frequent presenting symptoms were cough (59, 14.5%), musculoskeletal pain (55, 13.5%), and skin rash or boil (34, 8.4%). The median duration of illness at presentation was 7 (IQR 3–30) days. Two hundred thirteen (52.1%) patients had previously visited another healthcare provider for the same illness, with prior OPD evaluations among 114 (27.9%) patients, general practitioner visits among 81 (19.8%) patients, and traditional/Ayurvedic practitioner visits among 9 (2.2%) patients.

Table 1 Demographic and clinical characteristics of outpatients attending a public tertiary medical center in southern Sri Lanka (N = 409)

Clinical management during encounters

Twenty-three (5.6%) patients reported that they had been given a diagnosis by the physician during their clinical encounter. The majority of patients (379, 92.7%) were not asked to undergo further laboratory or radiographic studies as part of the diagnostic workup. Among patients who received further evaluation, the most frequently ordered studies were full blood count (14, 3.4% of all patients), urinalysis (14, 3.4%), blood glucose testing (4, 1.0%), radiography (2, 0.5%), and electrocardiogram (2, 0.5%). Medications were prescribed for 292 (71.4%) patients, of whom 56 (19.2%) reported that they were informed about the purpose of the prescribed medication(s) by their physician.

Antibiotic prescribing patterns

Antibiotics were prescribed for 146 (35.7%) patients, with the most common antibiotics being amoxicillin (41, 28.1% of antibiotic recipients), first-generation cephalosporins (38, 26.0%), and amoxicillin/clavulanate (30, 20.5%). Figure 1 depicts the distribution of prescribed antibiotics. Among patients receiving antibiotics, the most common presenting symptoms were cough (39, 26.7% of antibiotic recipients), rhinorrhea or nasal congestion (26, 17.8%), fever (18, 12.3%), skin rash or boil (9, 6.2%), sore throat (8, 5.5%), and skin wound (7, 4.8%). Amoxicillin and first-generation cephalosporins were most commonly prescribed for cough (36.6% of amoxicillin and 42.1% of first-generation cephalosporin recipients) and rhinorrhea or nasal congestion (22.0% of amoxicillin and 23.7% of first-generation cephalosporin recipients). In contrast, amoxicillin-clavulanate was most frequently prescribed for ear pain (7, 23.3%), fever (4, 13.3%), and cough (4, 13.3%).

Fig. 1

Antibiotics prescribed to outpatients attending a public tertiary medical center in southern Sri Lanka (N = 146)

Of the 141 antibiotic recipients with a documented duration of therapy, 135 (95.7%) received a 3-day course of antibiotic medication, the standard duration for medications dispensed through the OPD pharmacy. Diagnostic studies were ordered for 6 (4.1%) antibiotic recipients, and study results were not reviewed for any patient prior to receiving an antibiotic prescription. There was a non-significant trend towards increased antibiotic prescription among pediatric patients compared to adult patients (odds ratio [OR] 1.6, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.9–2.6, p = 0.08). Among adults, the likelihood of antibiotic prescription was similar among patients ≥65 years and patients 18–64 years (OR 1.09, 95% CI 0.49–2.34, p = 0.85). Adult patients reporting fever (OR 4.7, 95% CI 1.6–15.7, p = 0.002) or illness duration less than 7 days (OR 2.3, 95% CI 1.4–3.8, p = 0.001) were more likely to receive an antibiotic prescription; those who had prior evaluations for their current illness were less likely to receive an antibiotic (OR 0.5, 95% CI 0.3–0.8, p = 0.002; Table 2). Among children, patients with an illness duration less than 7 days (OR 2.6, 95% CI 1.0–7.3, p = 0.04) were more likely to receive an antibiotic. Antibiotic prescription did not significantly differ between respondents with ≥12th grade education compared to those with <12th grade education (OR 0.85, 95% CI 0.54–1.35, p = 0.51).

Table 2 Bivariable analysis of association between outpatient characteristics and antibiotic prescription at a public tertiary medical center in southern Sri Lanka

Antibiotics prescribed for respiratory illnesses

Overall, respiratory symptoms such as cough, rhinorrhea, congestion, wheezing, or shortness of breath comprised the largest indication (69, 47.3%) among patients receiving antibiotic therapy. Among patients with a presenting symptom of cough, 39 (66.1%) were prescribed antibiotics and 4 (7.7%) of these antibiotic recipients reported fever. Among those with rhinorrhea or congestion, 26 (78.8%) received antibiotics and none reported fever. Antibiotics were prescribed to 3 (60%) of 5 patients with a presenting symptom of wheezing and 1 (25%) of 4 patients with a presenting symptom of shortness of breath. The most frequently prescribed antibiotics among patients with respiratory indications were first-generation cephalosporins (26, 37.7%), amoxicillin (26, 37.7%), and second-generation cephalosporins (7, 10.1%). Among all antibiotic recipients with a respiratory presenting symptom, 2 (2.9%) underwent a diagnostic study and none underwent radiography.

Patient knowledge and expectations regarding antibiotic prescriptions

During pre-visit interviews, 359 (88.2%) respondents expected to be prescribed a medication during their visit and 2 (0.6%) specifically expected an antibiotic prescription. In post-visit interviews, 36 (9.1%) respondents reported knowledge regarding the purpose of antibiotics. After being provided with the definition of an antibiotic, 118 (29.4%) respondents thought that an antibiotic would be helpful for their illness. Among respondents who were prescribed an antibiotic, 32 (22.4%) were aware that they had been prescribed one, and 50 (35.2%) thought that an antibiotic would be helpful for their illness.

Visit satisfaction

Visit satisfaction was reported among 330 (84.8%) of all respondents. Among all respondents, there was a trend towards increased proportion of visit satisfaction among antibiotic recipients (OR 1.9, 95% CI 1.0–3.9, p = 0.05). Visit satisfaction was also greater among antibiotic recipients compared to those receiving prescriptions for other medications (OR 2.3, 95% CI 1.0–5.4, p = 0.03). The most frequently reported reasons for visit satisfaction included prescription of medications (190, 57.6%), satisfaction with the physical examination (49, 14.8%), and feeling that the physician listened to the patient (40, 12.1%). Among dissatisfied patients, 3 (5.1%) reported that lack of medication prescriptions contributed to visit dissatisfaction. Ninety (22.4%) patients planned to visit a different provider for their health concern.

Discussion

This single-center point-prevalence survey demonstrates a high prevalence of outpatient antibiotic prescription at a public tertiary medical center in southern Sri Lanka. Antibiotics were prescribed to approximately one-third of patients in this study, similar to the proportions of 33–54% reported in a 2015 World Health Organization audit of Sri Lankan OPDs as well as antibiotic prescribing figures reported in other South East Asian countries [8, 9]. These findings suggest that the prevalence of antibiotic prescription among outpatient care encounters in Sri Lanka may exceed that observed in some high-income settings; in comparison, an overall antibiotic prescription rate of 12% was previously reported in a nationally representative sample of ambulatory care visits in the United States [10]. However, prescription of broad-spectrum antibiotics was relatively infrequent in our study sample. Narrow-spectrum beta-lactam antibiotics represented the predominant choices for therapy while fluoroquinolone use was less frequent, which was consistent with Sri Lankan national clinical practice guidelines for common syndromes including lower respiratory tract infection and skin and soft tissue infection [11].

Our survey revealed limited knowledge and awareness of antibiotics and resultant low prevalence of expectations for antibiotic prescription among patients, suggesting that antibiotic prescribing behavior may have been driven by healthcare providers rather than by patient demand. These data support previous qualitative data from this outpatient setting showing that patient expectations for antibiotic prescription were uncommon [12]. In contrast, physicians’ perceptions that patients desire antibiotics have been identified as a major driver of antibiotic over-prescribing behavior in multiple studies [12,13,14]. As such, clinical guidelines and clinician training to improve rational antibiotic prescribing should include strategies to address both actual and perceived patient demand for antibiotics.

Of note, a high proportion of antibiotic prescriptions was given for treatment of respiratory syndromes. Patients with respiratory symptoms comprised nearly one-half of all antibiotic recipients. Conversely, a majority of patients with respiratory illnesses received an antibiotic prescription. These findings parallel previous observations in the inpatient setting in Sri Lanka, where lower respiratory tract infections were the most common indication for antibiotic therapy among hospitalized patients, as well as data from high-income countries showing high rates of outpatient antibiotic prescription for acute respiratory conditions [7, 10, 15]. Interventions targeting prescribing practices for acute respiratory tract infections thus represent a high-yield opportunity for antimicrobial stewardship. It was noteworthy that laboratory or radiographic evaluations to differentiate between upper and lower respiratory tract infections, or between viral and bacterial etiologies, were rarely performed in our study sample. Since the low utilization of diagnostic testing prior to antibiotic prescription may have been influenced by high patient volume and the desire to reduce costs in this public healthcare setting, cost-effectiveness and throughput of testing are important factors to consider when implementing interventions to potentially expand the use of diagnostics. Previous studies in Sri Lanka and other settings have shown that patients with a positive rapid influenza test had lower odds of receiving antibiotics, highlighting a potential role for rapid low-cost diagnostics in reducing antibiotic over-prescription [16, 17].

This study has several limitations. As a point prevalence survey, our data do not capture potential temporal variation in antibiotic prescribing practices in relation to seasonal illnesses such as influenza and dengue. The single center nature of this study precludes the generalization of findings to Sri Lanka due to potential differences between the public and private healthcare sector, primary and secondary/tertiary facilities, and different regions of the country in terms of physician prescribing behavior and patient population. Additionally, all clinical information except for antibiotics prescribed was based on patient self-report and thus may have been subject to reporting bias.

Conclusions

Antimicrobial stewardship represents a growing priority in Sri Lankan public health as well as the global health arena. Our study highlights a particular need for antimicrobial stewardship in ambulatory settings, for which there is limited experience in LMICs and a dearth of best practice guidelines. The development and scale-up of strategies to provide ongoing surveillance of antibiotic use, increase access to and utilization of diagnostic testing, and reinforce rational antibiotic prescribing practices will be important components in global efforts to control the spread of antimicrobial resistance.